Nicky's Pizzeria & Restaurant

This place is a hidden gem! I’ve been coming here since I was a kid, and it’s still one of my favorite regular pies in all of Westchester. That’s coming from somebody who has tried most of not all of the other pizza spots in the area. They also have tons of amazing specialty pies, but my personal favorite is the Buffalo Chicken shown in the photo. If you’re ever in the area, you should definitely stop by and grab a regular pie. You won’t regret it!

Nicky’s has been our local pizzeria for nearly 20 years. The staff treat me and my kids like family/old friends and remember your preferences (crispy or non crispy etc). The food is great, my kids love the BBQ pizza, Spicy Cup Pepperoni Grandma slice, the Buffalo Chicken slice or classic cheese. They have healthier options too like cheeseless Tomato and Garlic pie. Yum. They also got a pizza tag from the infamous pizza parlor graffiti artist. Look out for it on the side wall!

Nicky’s Pizza in Larchmont is the kind of spot everyone in town loves. The slices are classic New York style thin, crispy crust, rich tomato sauce, and just the right amount of cheese. You can taste the freshness in every bite. The Grandma pie is incredible, and their garlic knots are warm, buttery, and addictive. It’s a true neighborhood pizzeria! Friendly staff, quick service, and that cozy small-town vibe that makes you want to come back every week. Whether you live in Larchmont, Mamaroneck, or Rye, Nicky’s is the place for real Westchester pizza done right. Oh and they were so kind to my kids even when they got a little noisy.

I ordered three pizzas. 2 were correct, the third was supposed to have several toppings on it and it had no toppings. Just a cheese pizza. When I called them they said because it was Halloween they weren't doing toppings. I asked why they accepted the order and payment? They said the only way I could refunded for the wrong pizza was to contact Slice. Also, I ordered the pizza at 3pm for a 6pm delivery and I called them right after ordering to make sure they got it and to note it was for a later time. I don't know why they didn't tell me at that time they weren't doing toppings? The pizza isn’t even very good. It’s just the only close place close to my house. I won’t ever order from them again.

I cant believe I forgot about writing a review about my favorite pizzeria in all of westchester. These guys are the best when i mean the best in westchester i mean the best. I love coming in and getting the old school pizzeria vibes!