Nick's Pizza Lumberton

Some places just need to be shut down and not in business Coleslaw has way too much mayonnaise the fish believe it or not too fishy bad taste the crab cake totally fake not even a good quality fake ingredients The reason why I give the service one star is because the guy cooking the food doesn't wear a hairnet or gloves. The lady that reads you up at the register says one price but then charges you $1.85 processing fee even for a debit card which illegal federally and state by law I only order from them because they were the only place open during the storm which makes sense now. They must really need the business $94.64 down the drain ,🥱

I went to this pizzeria for the first time today. The exterior of the pizzeria is a little bland and blends in with the rest of the businesses. The interior is very nice with comfortable seating. The pizza and The cheesesteak that we ordered was very good and piping hot. I highly recommend this location.

This is a DISGRACE to NJ pizza. We usually order from Downtown Pizza in Mount Laurel (Phenomenal authentic pizza), but we were forced to try this place because we had just gotten back from an 8 hour drive and this was the only place open on a late Sunday night. Oh my, how we came to regret this decision. This pizza can best be described as “Chuck E Cheese” or “Middle School Cafeteria” pizza. Genuinely, this is a disgrace to NJ pizza. I’d rather dumpster dive or starve than eat even half of another slice from this place. Even frozen pizza puts this place to shame. You can go to just about any other pizza place in NJ and have a more authentic pie and an overall better experience than this one. I’m embarrassed to say that a place with this quality of pizza exists in our state.

Delicious pizza, thin with a crispy crust. Fried wings were to die for! Yummm🤤😍

We moved to the area recently and have tried plenty of pizza places near us, this is definitely our favorite. I can only speak on the cheese pizza, but it’s a classic, very reminiscent of a NYC dollar slice. Absolutely would recommend a cheese pie, it’s extremely reliable for a classic pizza slice.