Nick’s Pizza

I took my Sons here in March 2025 for a new place to Get Some pizza. My boys both love it and we wanted to find a different place to try….it was a great pizza. The indoor area was a little small but understandable because it wasn’t really a sit down type place more of a pick it up and go….but with the kids, we wanted to just eat there and they accommodated us very well! Pizza dough was great and we ate up the whole pie between the 3 of us!

First time ordering Nick’s Pizza and the food was not edible. First the cheese Calzone was burned outside and not fully cooked inside much of the dough inside was very undercooked. The pizza was burned, overcook and soggy crust. A good restaurant would not serve food in such condition. The cheese on the pizza had a dry elastic texture. One of the worst pizzas I have had in Pittsburgh. I understand by reading some of the reviews that these are not the original owners and most of the reviews were given prior. Very, very disappointed, a total waist of money!!!

I ordered takeout pizza from this location. 2 large pizzas. Both of them came to my house very undercooked to the point where it was inedible. When I called the store to let them know, they told me pretty much that I was lying and when I asked to talk to a manager they said to call back tomorrow and ask for “George”. I called back the next day and they said I’m sorry George isn’t here. Can you call back tomorrow again. So then I called back again today and they still said, I couldn’t talk to George and they refuse to give me a refund for my pizza that I had to completely thrown away. I’ve never dealt with such terrible service and will never be ordering from this place again. Which is a shame because I usually order from them quite often.

UPDATE: The follow up comment by the owner is even more proof of what I said in my review to be spot on. They even lied in their response. I spoke with the manager who spoke with the owner, and they decided to not work with me on multiple phone calls on multiple days. I was very nice, and gave them many chances. This place is a dirty horrible mess, you'll regret all of it, don't go here. ----- Bad quality, bad customer service, no accountability for dirty/contaminated/stale food/virus or bacteria infested food. I ordered a chicken bacon ranch XL. When I arrived for pickup, they were just making my pizza when I arrived. If you want a waste of time, money, and the contents of your bowels to be exited from your stomach, go to Nicks Pizza. I attempted to eat this dirty contaminated virus or ba

We ordered 8 pizzas for my daughter’s birthday. They faster than estimated, accurate, and delicious. Several people asked where the pizza was from because they enjoyed it so much!