Nick & Johnny's Osteria

We hadn’t been here in a few years. Started out with them not finding our reservation. Next it took a long time for a server. Ordered an appetizer and bottle of wine. App arrived but no silverware. Ordered dinner and it was a long wait. Food was very good, service not so much. Waited a long time for boxes. Got check pretty quick. Was overcharged for wine and both entrees. Told server and she said she’d take care of us. Took $10 off. Equalled $2 off after overcharges. Not sure if we’ll ever go back.

What a pleasant surprise having dinner tonight at Nick and Johnny’s not only was the food superb but the musical entertainment of Giorgio and Yolanda was spectacular. Don’t miss them.!!!

The eggplant parmigiana and tomato basil soup were delicious and a generous portion. Topped the meal off with an ice cream dessert! Our server was excellent. I preferred the seating in a booth in the bar area over a small table for 2 in the dining room area.

I never leave bad reviews but I feel this one is warranted. I called about a month in advance to make a reservation for Thanksgiving day for 12ppl. I asked the hostess are you open on Thanksgiving day, she replied yes, and put me down for the reservation. The day before, I called (at approximately @545 on Wednesday) to confirm my reservation and the hostess confirmed it for me. I did not think to get a name due to the fact that I had spoken to somebody twice with confirmation, I didn't even think there'd be any issues. Upon arrival on Thanksgiving day, we all pull into the parking lot and THE PLACE IS CLOSED. Not a soul in sight. I was flabbergasted. After numerous attempts to reach the restaurant, we finally spoke to the manager the next day, who also seemed shocked. The manager stated t

I sent a pic of my gnocchi dinner that I had Thursday night (on private FB message). I sent the gnocchi’s back because they were under cooked. I got the (very small portion) back - overloaded with gravy! My husband had ordered the bolognese without peas. It was served to us with peas so they took it back and made it without peas. The waitress felt bad and offered us a free dessert. When I got home and reread the receipt, I was charged 9.50 for peanut butter pie which was the only good thing we had. Do better please!!! We had invited another couple to join us and they were not pleased with their meal either. In addition, every time the door opened we were gagged with the smell of cigars. Apparently a men’s group of 6 like to smoke rather than eat. We actually drove down from Orlando - so