Nicholas Creamery Wall

Oh my gosh, this place was SO good. Move over Hoffman’s, Nicholas Creamery is where it’s at. The different flavor offerings are so great. I love that they have small batch seasonal rotations. The milkshakes are out of this world and last you 2 days. I kept half of mine for the next night and it was still good. They kind of skimp on the toppings, but they make up for it in creativity.

This place is honestly the best place to get ice cream in NJ! The ice cream itself is the perfect consistency! It's creamy but not too creamy and not too sweet! Every flavor that I have tried so far is absolutely perfect! This honestly says a lot considering that I worked in a different ice cream shop for 4 years! The prices are also the cheapest around! The only reason why I would take away a star is because I was here on a Friday night and they only had 3 people working. Put more people on the schedule!! Line out the door. Took a very long time just to put in an order and 1 out of the 3 workers were working on door dash orders. It was really just 2 people working on the line. Another thing that I noticed was that it was not very clean. Milk shake machine area was filthy and so was the to

Went here only because Strollo's Lighthouse in Oakhurst closed early due to the truly crappy weather on 10/12/2025. No fault of theirs, but I wanted to treat my wife on her birthday to a peanut butter Italian ice after a nice dinner at Talula's in Asbury Park. They were closed so we headed back towards our home in Point Boro and we were going to stop at Shop-Rite and pick up some manager's special desserts to bring home to enjoy with our kids. Before we pulled into the parking lot, my wife said, "Nicholas! Let's go to Nicholas Creamery... I hope they're open. Lights are on! Yes, they're open." So, at 8:40pm on Sunday during a Nor'Easter, we went inside. She'd been here before a couple times and always told me about the cool collaborations they do with local businesses like Rook Cof

I purchased the Peanut Butter Palooza 8-inch cake for $55 through your website on Wednesday 8/20/25 and unfortunately I was very disappointed. The cake I received looked nothing like the photos shown online, and the birthday topping I selected as an add-on was not included. Considering the price point, the quality and presentation did not meet expectations. Would not buy again.

As a self proclaimed ice cream connoisseur, this is definitely in my top 3. The unique flavors are what draws me in. The ice cream flight allows you to sample 4 of them, which is perfect! If you are reading reviews to decide to go, just go! It’s a must try. Worth the drive. Try something different. Live a little!