New York Pizzeria

We had a dinner party and ordered NYP, I’m so grateful for how easy it was to place my order—the whole process was smooth and stress-free! Everyone couldn’t stop talking about how delicious the food was. Thank you for making it such a great experience from start to finish!

Very cute pizzeria! The food is fresh and tasty, and the owner is very friendly. He surprised my husband and me with complimentary cannoli and espresso—this just made my day! :)

We were in town just one night for work, and got a later night snack after being on the road. We split a sausage, peppers and onion sub and 2 cannolis. The bread was just soooo good. Subs are good sized, with the cannoli it was plenty. Good ingredients and fully packed. The cannoli was very good, crisp shell and not too sweet filling that was full of chocolate chips. Wish we weren't leaving so early this morning so we could grab a bag of the sub rolls!

New York Pizzeria is always topnotch!! Food and service are always amazing! Love the subrolls they now sell as a 6-pack. The wine offered is very good as well as inexpensive! We are always greeted with a friendly face and a smile. While many restaurants have increased their prices, NYP prices seem to be the same. They truly care about their customers and community. If you have never been or haven’t been in a while, I strongly recommend you visit. You will not be disappointed!

At 4:30 this afternoon, I placed a takeout order and among those was Homemade Lasagna from the online menu. The ingredients listed everything that lasagna comes with including meatballs. When I called back an hour later to report there were no meatballs with the Lasagna, I was told that meatballs have to be ordered as a side dish. There is nothing in the online menu that indicates this. Furthermore, I was told if I ordered this again, to order the meatballs on the side. I will not be ordering again, period!