New York Pizzeria

Is the best. Their prices are unmatched. The food is tops. Very clean. Very good. Best pizza in area. I do like them, I will drive by many pizza shops to come to this one. Five stars.

This place is just not what it used to be. We used to have reliably delicious food here for most of my life, but the last half dozen times we've ordered pizza or subs, either the order is completely incorrect or the pizza is just mediocre with the cheese falling off and the dough being undercooked or overcooked. In my most recent order, I ordered a chicken cordon bleu sub and was asked if I wanted bleu cheese still with the additional toppings I ordered, but I recieved a cheeseburger sub with lettuce and mayo. There was also a philly cheesesteak with peppers onions and mushrooms and provolone on the order. What we got was just the beef, the cheese and the bread. The quality and care for the product they are selling is just not there anymore in my opinion. It feels wrong not to recommend th

I'm a truck driver and here lately I've been picking up in Cato. Finally decided to try this place and to be honest they have some of the best wings I've ever had. The wings, Jenny style and charbroiled were just amazing. The pizza was made with fresh ingredients and just as amazing. The people working that night were real nice. Highly recommend and can't wait to get back there for the wings.

Always been the absolute best place to get pizza and wings. I dont know if theres new owners making changes or what. Tonight the wings were way over cooked, the bbq sauce is different now or it was just old, the cheese was rubbery and pulled right off the slice.

I've been a customer for about 30 years and it used to be the best pizza. These years it has declined in quality and consistency, significantly. It makes me very sad. Unfortunately, there are better choices now; places worth driving 20 minutes further for. I hope they return to their former glory. It used to be a point of pride, being from the area. People who think it's good now have no idea what they missed out on.