New York Pizza

Just received my order 20 minutes ago , ordered a large cheeseburger sub , took one bite and it was more bread than anything else , both half’s of the sub look exactly the same. This is a large sub supposedly. This was my first time ever ordering from here because I was told the food is good. But from what I got I disagree completely. If I wanted just a bread I could have eaten that at home rather than ordering from here. Beyond disappointed and never again, in addition I ordered chocolate cake , and was sent a spoiling curled tiramisu instead

The cheese and pepperoni pizza were very good. The white pizza was just alright, didn’t taste fresh and too much garlic. Crust tasted stale. Will be back to try the chicken bacon ranch and Buffalo chicken which looked great in the store

I got the chicken margarita pizza. Did not like that the whole pizza was covered in wilted basil leaves also large slices of garlic, slices of tomato and slabs of chicken which made it hard to eat. The sauce was very good and also the crust. Just a suggestion: cubed chicken tomato and chopped garlic and less basil would be so much better! I was disappointed because it's hard to get good Italian Pizza in the Bridgewater area!

Ordered Delivery. The website said 35-45min delivery time. Over an hour went by and the store was closed. I ordered the food at 8pm and it got left at my front door at 9:45pm. When I called the store the next morning they told me I was lying about when the food was dropped off. I told them I had ring cam footage and he continued to call me a liar. Food was cold. I was told I would not get a refund. Super rude staff

Got takeout on a busy Friday night. They forgot an item and handled the mistake very well. Plus gave us a giant cookie for the troubles. Very good food, decent prices and great service. 4 stars for atmosphere. Nothing wrong with it, just a basic takeout out pizza place.