Mystic Pizza II

Had a really solid pizza here this afternoon with my wife. We had a half Margarita and half Gotti Clams Casino pizza, and I must admit: very good! Unlike most Greek pizzerias, this crust was thin and crispy with just the right crunch. The clams were fresh and the proportion of bacon was great. The best part of our experience was Jess: she was incredibly helpful, professional, and very sweet. The atmosphere is great as well, reminiscent of the movie, though this is not the original location. But don't let that deter you from coming here because the food is significantly better than the original location. This was our first visit but it certainly will not be our last! Thanks again Jess!

Our server Daniela was incredible! The food was amazing my father in law and oldest loved the cheesy garlic bread and marinara so much we got another order to go! My husband got the meatballs appetizer and it was incredible. I highly recommend!

Mystc Pizza is NOT what it used to be. $30 pizza with artichokes (4 pieces ) and onions (paid extra) roasted red peppers ( missing in action apparently). Have been a loyal customer for years but this is my LAST Mystic Pizza. Talk about screwing your customers. Shameful

I have always driven by but never had the time to stop by but today I had plenty of time and decided to dine in. The pizza was delicious and Annette who work the bar was as also amazing and very pleasant. I am a native NY’er and somewhat of a pizza snob and Mystic certainly passed muster. If you are ever in the area, this is a stop to make for pizza or something else off their menu.

Classic place nice atmosphere. Great service! Fries were hot and tasty. Pizza was pretty good too.