Mystic Lobster Roll Co - Naples, Vanderbilt Shoppes

Love this restaurant. Of course the lobster rolls are amazing, so fresh and juicy. But what I love is the service here. Austin is very friendly, attentive and gives the best food recommendations ever. We really enjoyed talking to him!

I cannot tell you enough how great this place is. I walked in told them to surprise me with a lobster roll and make it however they wanted. This thing was the best lobster roll and lobster bisque I’ve ever had. Such great customer service as well!!! This place is hours from my house but everytime I’m in town I come here. It’s hands down the best lobster roll I’ve ever had. 10 stars ⭐️

We’re big lobster roll fans and like to try what we can when we’re in a new city. Highly recommend this place! Wonderful friendly service. Rolls made fresh to order. Lots of meat. Amazing flavour! We had a Connecticut and a Maine roll and couldn’t decide on our favourite.

This was the best lobster I've had in a long time and shocked to find it in Naples. The meat was so tender and sweet and the ratio of meat to bun was perfect . I had the ct lobster roll in the photo and my husband had a traditional New England one. We live in ct and my husband grew up in MA so we eat a lot of lobster rolls in the summer and this one compares to the best in New England .

This was a very casual restaurant with friendly service. The decor of the interior was bland and had a cafeteria like atmosphere. We enjoyed the Connecticut Lobster roll, but I wasn't blown away where I felt I had to return to the restaurant for more. Thought they were a little stingy on the lobster and placed the lobster on the top of the bun to give illusion of more. They didn't serve french fries as some of these pictures in earlier reviews imply. In fact, the server said they changed the menu and removed it from the menu. Felt it was over priced for the level of restaurant style and presentation.