Mystic Island Pizza

My wife's family has been coming here for years and I just started as well. They have great pizza and wings. I was a little disappointed in the calamari it was just large rings I honestly thought they were onions rings at first, would love if they switch to small calamari with the tenicles just like at Italian restaurants. Other then that it's a great place, the customer service is amazing, great people to talk to. Plus that are Eagels fans what more can you ask for.

5 slices of pizza $ 28.45. Rip off! Not going back. Worse than boardwalk pizza prizes on summer time!

Connie👌🏾- Well I entered and the staff was very friendly- inside was warm and nice and sounded like home. I don’t go crazy over pizza so it took me a “moment” to decide🤔 Connie- who eventually took my order, gave me a history of the place, listened to how I ended up there -was a ball of 😂. As I waited for the food I walked around and took the pictures below- I was not sure how the food would have tasted but I know that I felt like I was a long standing customer around friends. I went in as a stranger and I felt I left as a friend. My hour long drive back home was more calming than my hour long drive to “nowhere” in particular. I guess the “magic” of Mystic Island resides in its people‼️ and the water💯❤️🇯🇲

First and last time trying. Thin, greasy, and nasty. Waited 45 minutes for one pepperoni pizza. If I could add a picture of this atrocious mess I would. Honestly shocked this place has good reviews. I couldn’t eat anything but the crust and even that sucked. So disappointing I waisted my time.

I stopped in on a whim, never been there before. When I went to the counter to order, I took the menu and as I was looking over at the woman at the register came over and I don’t know it started to pressure me to make a decision and then she started to read the menu to me like I was an idiot and couldn’t read. I finally ordered the veal Parmesan with shrimp entrée and I asked her if the veal was tenderize (Ground Up into patties) or “real veal“. Well, the good news is it was real veal, but it was also real tough. The shrimp was delicious the sauce and the pasta were delicious, but the veal was pretty Bad.