Mulberry Street Bay Shore

We are always pleasantly surprised by the food quality and portions for the price and we’re equally happy tonight. The food is well prepared and very tasty. Server was excellent. My seafood pasta di mare was on the specials menu and was fantastic with at least 2 dozen mussels included in a tasty vodka sauce with shrimp scallops and crab meat mixed in. My lady had the eggplant, chicken parm and stuffed shells also from the specials menu and was equally satisfied. We’ve eaten here a number of times and haven’t been disappointed.

Staff was very pleasant taking my phone order. The gentleman was competent taking the order. My wife ordered a Meatball Parm hero to go I ordered the Broccoli and Rigatoni.. Her hero she said was very good...My dish however, was over cooked. I'm Italian so kind of know how pasta should be cooked..The Penne pasta was mushy, chewy but not al dente chewy, if you get my drift. The broccoli was falling apart, mushy as well..Otherwise the taste was ok, not too salty, not too much garlic...Pick-up was seamless, no problem, in and out...

Place can easily seat parties of 4 or less. The pizza here is sublime. The flavor for the pizza is unmatched and their other dishes are superb as well like their pasta. My only critique is if you order a normal pie the slices might be very wilted but that's not an issue because of how good it is. Simply ask for crispy crust when ordering a pizza pie or ask for your pizza to be well done.

Been here many times and am always very well taken care of. The food is great and staff treats you like family. The owner seems like a genuinely good man too

Nice and local is the only way these days, love to support the small guy! This place is one of the few places that still serves a meal at a great price! One less star for the help trying their best but just not enough attention given due to being short staffed... obviously a problem these days but still worth noting. Surely still a place everyone should visit too, a place they will be very happy when the check arrives!