Mr Pizza's Pasta House

A small cozy spot that delivers tasty and delicious food! Very welcoming and hasty service from Joann! We got the mozzarella sticks and the stuffed artichoke as apps. The sticks were so cheesy and savory. The stuffed artichoke was a little runny so that made it a little hard to eat but def delicious. The rice ball was massive and def could’ve been its own mini meal. The pasta bread bowls were so pleasant and palatable! Penne with chicken was flavorful and satisfying. Water refills were a must and on point! Stellar!

Best pizzeria!! My family and I love Mr Pizza! Everything we have ever ordered is excellent- pizza, salads, wraps, dinners, catering- you can’t go wrong! Always delicious and fresh. The owner and staff are so genuinely pleasant, helpful, friendly, and hardworking. Love the vibe and appreciate them so much :)

Mr. Pizza is my favorite pizza spot on the island, maybe even in all of New York! I grew up around here, and would often go to Mr. Pizza’s afterschool with friends or a quick trip before a game starts. The pizza always comes out fresh, hot, cheesy, just the right amount of everything. The cashier is the sweetest lady ever, alongside the rest of the staff. Not to mention, the pizza is extremely affordable! Many places in the city cannot compare to this.

Today, I was able to place an order upon walking in, super fast, no wait time at all. I sat inside and was able to admire the atmosphere of the establishment while I waited for a yummy grandma pie to be created in the kitchen. The decor selection was really unique and stylish, it felt very distinguished to me, personally. Beautiful Tiffany lamps all over as well as a red tiled ceiling, and farmhouse style furniture options. For a small space, they really made the best of it, and had plenty of seating available. The grandma pie was very good, different from what I've had in Brooklyn. The crust is a big thicker than I'm used to on a grandma slice, a bit salty but it mixed well with the toppings. My family finished the entire pie within minutes of it arriving at the table, so that is saying

Service was top-notch—super friendly, attentive, and fast. Our server was welcoming, checked in often, and made sure everything was perfect. They even boxed up leftovers nicely and brought extra sauce without us asking. Genuine, warm hospitality.