Mr Crabby's Seafood House & Sports Bar (NJ)

UPDATE: Stopped in Sat Nov 15th to see the live band - "Sick Star Nation" 9pm, who were awesome! Played a variety of songs - rock, pop, country and top hits!!! Mr. Crabby's was packed with some fun people!! *Thank you Tatiana - our server who was pleasant, friendly, attentative & she recommended some great choices to eat! Low Country BOIL, Avocado Citrus Salad w Grilled Salmon, steamers & mussels, and delicious calamari !! Will be back !!! Stop in for Happy Hour: Mon-Fri. 3pm to 6pm. They have a great menu selection - seafood & more! See their website!! Sat at the spacious bar and had a dozen oysters. Staff were awesome - shout out to bartender/server Juliana and Brian, as well as the bar-back Dali, for making sure everything was was cleaned and stocked. Met with one of the owners - Nico,

If I could give a hundred stars I could! Sully gave IMMACULATE service and hospitality. His skills at communicating and connecting to people is unmatched. He made my order of Tuscan Salmon personally and I could tell he made it with love and care! The wings, drinks, and shrimp we got were also incredible! My girlfriend and I will be coming back and dining here again.

Edit update: Went back for a 2nd try and it was a completely different experience from months ago. Food was amazing! Our waiter "Sully" was very friendly and knowledgeable. I'm glad we went back! We were 1 of 2 tables dining and the wait time for drinks /apps/food took longer than expected. - Food was underwhelming and expensive, especially for what you are presented with. They were out of most things (like crab). Service was great, our waiter was friendly and apologetic about the many issues coming from the kitchen (that we knew weren't his fault). Trivia night was fun. Bartender was not skilled. Fun place for trivia night, eat before you go.

Always a great time at Mr. Crabby’s in Randolph. Fun bar atmosphere, solid food, and a great beer selection including Hoboken Brewing. Easy place to hang out and unwind.

I do not recommend this place. Very poor quality food. Slow service. The crab dip was more of a melted cheese dip. The worst and smallest lobster roll I’ve ever had. The lobster was in chewy tiny little pieces. Poor quality tuna, tough and didn’t taste fresh. The clams were overcooked and tough. Basic cocktails, not great. None of us were pleased with our entrees. Save your money and go somewhere else as it was expensive for the quality. It’s a sports bar setting. Big parking lot.