Mr. and Mrs. P's Eatery

I truly cannot say enough wonderful things about Mr. & Mrs. P’s Eatery — both their restaurant and their catering services are exceptional. My parents have used them for years to cater a wide variety of events and have always raved about the food and service. I’ve been lucky enough to attend several of those events myself, and every experience has been consistently outstanding. So when it came time to plan our wedding in Green Lake, Wisconsin, I knew immediately that I wanted Mr. & Mrs. P’s to cater. They are, without question, the best choice in the area. Their restaurant dishes — from breakfast to lunch — are always flavorful and perfectly prepared, but their talents extend far beyond the eatery. With their high-end catering expertise, Kathy, Kim, and Joe helped me design the most inc

Pretty decent. The white chocolate macaroon mocha was great! I don't usually order soup, but I'm so glad I did! The potato leek was delicious! Great flavor. The country skillet was average. I'm not a huge fan of the really small potatoes and they really loaded on the mushrooms which became the dominating flavor. The desserts in the case up front looked very tasty but I didn't order any. I'd go back and would just order something different.

We stopped by for lunch. Really liked the variety focused on breakfast, great lunch options and a variety of deserts. The portions were larger than expected. Everything came to the table fresh and hot. The service was good, allowed time to make our decisions and didn’t hurry us off when we were done. Casual atmosphere, perfect for catching up with family or friends. Thank you!

Excellent food. Variety of seating options- counter, table, booth. Everything prepared under the watchful eyes of, and much directly by the owner, “Mr. P.”. Open Wednesday through Sunday, closes at 2p each day. Special the past few weeks is amazingly good blackened salmon served on a bed of garden fresh beans, accompanied by cilantro micro greens, sweet corn. The French fries are home cut, double fried. Most highly recommend.

This restaurant has a great cozy atmosphere, a menu that caters to multiple diet types, and wonderful friendly service. They have a better selection and flavor of coffee than Starbucks by far, including non dairy milk options and their mimosas are delicious. Breakfast is a little limited for a vegan like myself but I don’t mind just ordering a side of rye toast and fruit, especially with their crafted jellies that change with what fruits are in season. It is usually busy but they have a nice seating area with a fireplace that makes the wait easier plus it gives you the chance to look at all their same day crafted pastries. This is a treat for me and my partner to go to for breakfast on the weekends.