Mister Goodies Ice Cream

Dude! This Pickle Loves Ice Cream and He Loves Nachos! The First Time I went I had Ice Cream Nachos and I bring My Sweet Gherkin-Granny. She and I enjoyed it so much, I brang my Nephews, Wilbur and Dann-it with my Sweet Bread and Butter Wife to Enjoy Ice Cream. Nice Employees. Speedy Service and Fresh never Melted Ice Cream.

Big selection. Good ice cream. Fun crowd. What else do you need?

Audrey and Skyler were very friendly and appreciative of my entire party as we ordered. Would come back because staff like these ladies make the experience memorable.

4.5.2025, the soft serve was not prepared/ mixed well today. We asked for cones and instead they gave us bowls with watery ice cream. I have had better experiences here before so I am unsure why today was so bad. If the owners see this please take some steps to remedy this issue. UPDATE: I previously listed this as the BackYard location in Forest. This was my mistake, the location was actually the Timberlake location. The BackYard location is where we went to get another cone and their product was normal/satisfactorily made. Additionally, I am updating to 3 star to reflect the responsiveness of the business to my review.

The BEST in all of Lynchburg! Even if there’s a long line, don’t worry—these owners know exactly how to keep things moving. Their leadership is top-notch. They’re always hands-on, guiding both customers and employees smoothly while engaging in friendly conversation the whole time. It's some of the best customer service I’ve ever experienced! Now let’s talk about the ice cream—absolutely amazing. The portions are generous, the flavors are on point, and every visit hits the spot. If you haven’t tried Mister Goodies Ice Cream yet, what are you waiting for? Go treat yourself—you won’t be disappointed!