Millie's of Staten Island

Came here with a large group of friends for a holiday dinner and was incredibly impressed. Friendly service, great atmosphere, large selection of brews and cocktails. We ordered the porterhouse for 2 and was genuinely shocked how fantastic it was. Perfectly cooked, juicy, and delicious. Plenty of app and sides to choose from. This spot and a hidden golden nugget on Staten Island. Would absolutely come back here again.

I gotta give Milley's a 5 star across-the-board. If food is great, the service is unbelievable. The atmosphere is very good.Good place to get a good meal at a reasonable price.

I had a surprising experience here. Came once a few years ago and it didn’t blow me away. Came back for Valentines day 2026 Wow, BLEW ME AWAY. Dry aged Ny strip was outstanding, the wood fired pizza phenomenal. Friendliest staff in the world. A great great treat. Thank you

I went to Millie’s for lunch right when they opened and was appalled by how dirty it was. There were food crumbs all over the floor, the booths, and even the menus — which were greasy and sticky. It honestly looked like the place hadn’t been cleaned in ages. On top of that, there was a strong smell of pesticides, which was very unpleasant and concerning. With the buffet of food on the floor it would make complete sense if they had roaches . Between the lack of cleanliness and the strange odor, I couldn’t even enjoy my meal. I won’t be coming back. The pictures do not explain how bad this truly was. I wiped before I sat and still had things underneath me.

I can’t believe I hadn’t tried Mille’s before, especially since it’s right in the neighborhood! I was pleasantly surprised by how good it was. We ordered a specialty pizza, and it was fantastic. The meatballs and chicken parm were also good—classic dishes that some places get wrong, but Mille’s absolutely nailed them. That said, there are a couple of things I’d tweak. The menu is a bit overwhelming with too many options—cutting it in half and focusing on doing a few dishes really well could make a big difference. (But what do i know )Also, they could benefit from hiring an additional bartender. The bar scene was picking up as we were leaving, and quicker service would really enhance the experience. Overall, Mille’s delivers on flavor and atmosphere, and I’ll definitely be back!