Middleton Diner

For the type restaurant it is the setting is fine. Sometimes I think it could be twice as large because it’s so business. Sometimes few buffets these days but here is one. It’s about 55 miles away but we slip up occasionally for a good and reasonable meal. When we spent the summer up that way a whole group of us would go. They easily sat 10 of us. And with it being an affordable meal we mostly got the buffet so we had our meal quickly. Good salad bar. Personally I can’t eat a lot but the buffet is still the best deal for me. I like that bit of variety. Kind and pleasant staff who add peace to your meal.

Outstanding menu/buffet selection! Amazing wait staff! Everyone, including back of the house, hustles their tails off! Everything at affordable prices!

Really nice relaxing small town diner, the staff are super friendly and helpful during the entire time I was there. My little sister and I both ordered burgers because honestly it’s a staple food lol, but regardless they tasted amazing and did not disappoint at all. The fries were well salted and the coleslaw tasted great. And best yet all the food was hot and fresh which isn’t very common these days at a lot of restaurants. 10/10 I hope I’m driving through the area again sometime soon so I can come again.

Small town diner with good food and friendly people. Used to come here a lot when I lived in Ithaca, and both my parents lived around here a bit back in the late 1930's. This was the kind of place they always took us when we went out for a family dinner. Plenty of parking - and the pies are great, so save room for dessert!

We were on a road trip and decided to try their buffet. It was a small buffet the stuffing was bland and just mush. The ham was formed ham in a lot of liquid so was the roast beef in a lot of liquid. Even the yams were in a lot of liquid. The lettuce had brown edges on the salad bar. My wife took a couple of bites of the chicken and didn't want anything else. The waitress never came back to our table. Understandably this is a small town with nothing else around. We didn't try the pie or baked goods but I will say the homemade beans were good. All in all unimpressive. Was expecting more quality from all the positive reviews.