Merritt Bakery

It’s always a walk back in time when I enter Merritt Bakery. Having worked there as a teenager, I remember the quality and abundance of all the baked goods. The family recipes have remained the same and Mike the Baker continues to use the finest quality ingredients, just like his parents Joan & Mike used to do. I left with a custom 10” square strawberry shortcake for my mother in law’s birthday that was divine - fresh and light, and two pounds of their scrumptious chocolate dipped cookies. Simply the BEST!

Need cookies? Fresh delicious cookies? This bakery is 10 star not 5 star. Their cakes, cookies, pastries are top notch. The owner is friendly and makes you want to stay and talk. In Farmingdale or near Farmingdale stop and partake of this bakery goodness.

Perfect Barbie cake for my 4 year old! The cake was gorgeous and delicious. Moist and perfectly layered. I’ve been using this bakery for years and am always blown away with their quality products. The baker is an artist. I’ve also ordered custom cupcakes.

Great whoopee pie, black and white cookies. My wife's cake looked incredible!!! They are worth the trip. Please support a good local business. They are so cordial with the customers that I would not mind driving the 20 minutes to this location. Black and White cookie!!!! Jelly Donut and Boston Creme Donuts are my favorite!!!!

OMG!!! I bought a carrot cake for a small celebration and the cake is mind blowing. So rich, creamy and nutty it just can’t get better. The lady was super sweet as well!! Definitely recommend don’t miss out heaven on your tongue.