Meetinghouse Deli

This place hasn't changed in 40 years. Still has fantastic food with a real North fork local feel. The breakfast special is a great deal. You get an egg sandwich, small or medium coffee, and an orange juice for about $7.25. BECSP..... IYKYK

If I could give this Deli zero stars, I wouldn’t hesitate in a heartbeat. Look at this sorry looking hero bread, lettuce, tomato and did I mention “Tuna” or lack of said Tuna! It’s not like we haven’t been here before, we’re local folks, but unfortunately this tuna hero absolutely sucked. If I wanted a lettuce tomato hero I would have asked for it. I understand the economy is bad, and cutting back seems logical, but, charge more for a decent sandwich, don’t sell crap and expect return customers. With that said, I would suggest buying a $1 dollar can of tuna and make your own sandwich. If you expect to receive good value for your money, you’re not going to find it here at this Deli. So much for having lunch out and expecting it to be exceptional.

I stop in whenever passing through LI. Always good quality food and good portions too. Interesting deli options too. Posted the menu for others to see since they dont have paper or online copies available. Recommended! Thank you will be back!

The food is acceptable, but the portions are small. I recommend avoiding ordering eggs over easy right before 11:00, as the woman cooking tends to get upset due to her menopause. I won't be returning, which is unfortunate because I've been going there since I was a child. However, I refuse to pay $26 for egg sandwiches only to receive the wrong order and an attitude.

We have enjoyed Meetinghouse for years. Today was a disappointment. They were short staffed, and that was a factor for sure. I ordered two sandwiches, and they were made without the ordered tomato, and the lettuce was barely present. Unfortunately, the portion of roast beef and turkey was about 1/3 less than it has been. What was there was very good, but without the side dill slice, it was lacking. Hopefully, the next time will be better. Everyone has a less than great day now and then.