Maxie's Supper Club & Oyster Bar

The wife and I went here on a Friday night early (4pm) glad we had reservations because this place was hopping moments after we arrived. Incredibly attentive service from the moment we walked in. As far as food goes.. wow. Clearly fresh and quality ingredients used with all of their dishes. My fish fry was easily one of the best I've had in years. Nicely battered, not too thick and great taste. Fries are hand cut which means they are already 100times better than most out there. Great corn bread to start as well. Can't say enough good things. This is a new place on our list.

The best food in Ithaca hands down (and the only good seafood). I’m from Alaska so my bar for fresh seafood is high and Maxie’s had some of the freshest oysters and fish I have ever had! Cooked to perfection and the ambiance is so nice. Delightful experience. Do yourself a favor and step outside your comfort zone here. The shrimp&grits and jambalaya are delicious but their fish dishes (Ahi, specials, etc) are where they really shine.

Loved this Southern spot! Ordered a lot of food but loved the gumbo, clams and the fried chicken -- the latter wasn't too oily and was delicious. The raw platter was also super fresh and tasty. Didn't care for the crabcake, but everything else was great. A little pricey but came away very satisfied.

Hands down the best food I had while vacationing in Ithaca. My mushroom meal & the coconut banana crème pie were both incredible. The only downside is we were seated in the back area which was an enclosed patio type room & it was SO HOT. They have a fan running but it didn’t help much; I was sitting there sweating.

This place came recommended by a friend and it was lovely! The staff was great and the food was delicious! I didn't take a photo, but get the Caesar salad, it was the best I ever had! I also got a ¼ pound of peel and eat shrimp and it was amazing! My husband enjoyed the catfish.