Matt's Pizza

I have been ordering pizza from Matt’s since I moved here 8 years ago. Delicious pizza. Prompt delivery. I used to ask for “well done not burnt “ after a year or two I asked for“well done because they knew already. It was always perfect. Tonight we ordered aSicilian pie. Burnt to where it was almost unrecognizable Definitely not edible. . I’m wondering was this business sold. Either way, I will be looking for another pizza place.

My husband fondly remembered Matt’s from his teenage years (around 1993 - 1995). When we stumbled on it on New Year’s Day (while searching for an open bagel store) he was so happy to find it and told me it Matt’s was the best pizza he’s ever had. He was RIGHT! We have pretty much ordered every week since then with no plans to stop and I must say— this is easily the best pizza I’ve had in my 40+ years on Long Island. I’m mad we didn’t realize it was there sooner but better late than never 😂 We always get the Garlic Knot Pizza and Pasta with Alla Vodka Sauce- HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!

Very disappointed this use to be our go to pizza place basically once a week for years since we moved to coram and it so close. I am not sure what has changed but over the last few months things haven’t been the same. The food isn’t as good as it once was.The sauce doesn’t taste the same at all and the meals I use to order don’t either for example one of the things I use to order was The chicken roll which was a favorite of mine but the last few times it barely had any chicken on it or sauce and they gave all different size rolls some smaller then others and it didn’t appear to be the same amounts on each one and when I questioned it the worker said it is something with the ratio but they all have the same amount inside which isn’t true but I pay the same amount whether it’s smaller or n

I got a couple different kinds of pizza tonight from Matt's for the first time ever. I think it's the best crust I've ever had, they should definitely be in the running for best pizza on Long island. The sauce is perfect, a little sweet, the staff were very respectful... we will be back!

Drove 30 to 40 minutes in the rain just to get some pizza from this place that was originally my childhood pizzeria in Islip Terrace. Food is just as great as i remembered it, customer service is amazing, and the atmosphere is very welcoming as it always was. Well worth the drive and extremely recommended to everyone!