Mattingly's Tavern

The perfect tavern wrapped in baseball history! The grilled chicken sandwich with bacon and cheddar on a pretzel bun was great but the fries were the best I’ve had in my life - seriously! Good beers and bourbon.

Great place to get a quick bit and a beer. Friendly staff and fun group of customers. Trivia night was fun.

I have been to Mattingly's several times now. I live on Long Island, but stop off here on the way up to Sullivan County. The owner, Tom, is always super polite and welcoming. The bartenders are also extremely friendly, no matter when I go. They have a flawless upgraded Golden Tee '26 cabinet, which is extremely tough to find in the Hudson Valley. If I lived closer, I would live at this bar! 😁 Cheers!!

I'd give this bar a 3.5/5. The bartender was super sweet and attentive. My fish and chips and my husband's burger were perfectly cooked. The Mattinglys dry rub wings were insanely salty. The bar top is crazy wonky lol and when I wiped some tartar sauce off the bar, my napkin was black. Could definitely stand to replane the wood on the bar tops.

Great wing and bar type food. I went with 4 friends for drinks and apps. Nice waitress made us laugh. Cool overall vibe. Recommend.