Mary Zifer's Pizza Shop

Unfortunately, I had better experiences of this place 20 years ago than I did recently. The cheesy bread with sauce, almost made me throw up after the first bite. When I told the waitress she kind of just stared at me. I guess I kind of expected her to take it off the bill. There was something in the drinks floating around. The lights above the table are like a heat lamp. It was very uncomfortable to even sit at the table because I felt like I was roasting. Pizza itself was pretty bad. I spent the next two days very sick.🤢 Don't eat here. It's just not a good environment anymore and the food's not that good. What a shame.

Fast, friendly service. Very helpful with menu offerings. Had a small thin crust pepperoni pizza with onions and green bell peppers. Had a really crunchy crust but tasted really good. Wife had spaghetti with meatballs. Both tasted good too

Excellent pizza at a reasonable price! It's good family dining.

I'll start with service was good. Waitress was very friendly and attentive. Not a lot of choices for people who cant do red sauce, no alfredo sauce for pasta or pizza and no italian subs at a pizza place? Only meatball and sausage...with red sauce. The house dressing for the salad was good! We also found it strange that they use a yellow cheese on their pizzas. Ok for a one time thing but we probably wouldnt stop again.

The crust, cheese, and sauce were good, but the green peppers and mushrooms seemed to come from a can and were a little unappetizing. I prefer fresh ingredients. Also, I wasn't crazy about the sausage.