Marty's Pizzeria

Food was so good and surprisingly enough? The salad that came with and before the food was great and I'm honestly not used to that. Worthwhile food. I hope I get to try the pizza soon! Update 10/18/2025 The second time I've walked into this place and I got nothing but a silent stare and a face like I didn't belong. The food wasn't nearly as good as the first time. The spaghetti and meatballs were awful simply because those meatballs could be used in case the Flyers lose a hockey puck they were so dry and flavorless but on top of it all, instead of giving a proper greeting with a smile instead of awkwardness or good service in general, I'm met with a weird look over and over and a $22 bill I should've never paid for such mediocre service and food today and no, I won't be back. Get your pe

You Need To Know? This was a pleasant find in the neighborhoods of Nanticoke. Arrived around 5:45 and it was busy. By the time we left there was not a seat available. The two girls working the floor were busting there ass & made for a great team. The food is fantastic with homemade dishes. We tried the homemade pierogis, pizza, wings (red garlic), homemade meatball sandwich, homemade piggies, & a surf & turf cheeseburger 🍔. The food was very flavorful & well worth a visit when you are near Nanticoke. The only knock was the burger was served with tartar sauce, because of the crabcake on it but we didn't like the mixture with the burger. Personal choice. Now You Know! -TBH

We ordered out so we didn't get to deal with much of the service. It's Friday night and I know that means it's crunch time in a restaurant I've worked in MANY before. We ordered 4 things technically 3. We decided on 2 crab stuffed mushrooms, that tasted like there crab has been sitting out for a week, a chicken bacon ranch pizza with broccoli, which wasn't bad for the free extra toppings we didn't ask for like a couple uncooked onions and half backed tomatoes but I guess they were used becuase they ran out of baconor something, and mild wing bites, that were just a bit dry. Crab stuffed mushrooms should not be almost 10 bucks when your getting something like that back. We've been here not that long ago and raved about the food. I really hope you didn't get a new chef, and we were very disa

First time trying Marty's in Nanticoke. The pizza was amazing. The crust made the pizza top notch. The bites were good too.

Been to Marty’s many times and recommend to many people. This past visit was a total disappointment. We met with a group of 8 for dinner on a Friday. We started to oder and was told there was nothing available with crab. No appetizer, no entrée. OK. How about some garlic knots. None! This is a pizza place, garlic knots are made with dough!! Next, we went the pizza route. After our oder was placed (15 minutes later), we were told it would be an hour wait! We finally got our fried pizza, and it tasted like the oil was a month old and rancid. It's a bitter disappointment for a generally good dinner choice.