Martha's Country Bakery

Cramped seating with mediocre desserts. We had the cheesecake, fudge cake, and stuffed peanut butter cookie. The best by far was the stuffed peanut butter cookie. It was served warm with lots of gooey peanut butter in the center. It was pretty good! The fudge cake was dry and stiff like it was sitting in the case for a week. The frosting was good though. My husband didn’t think the cheesecake was good. I’d possibly give it another shot and order another peanut butter cookie, but won’t go out my way to come again.

My Absolute Favorite Cake Shop in the USA! 🎂✨ I cannot say enough good things about this place. It is, without a doubt, my favorite cake shop in the entire country. They have been a part of every major milestone in my life, and they never fail to impress.

please note all the toppers I PROVIDED. I Got a cake for my daughter’s birthday, they forgot to write the message i gave. Day of pick up i had to ask for it… they wrote it in a blue i did not ask for and wrote it on top when i specifically asked for it on the front because i had toppers. please note i was not charged extra for the “decorations” I tried to order another cake today- asked for an explanation of the “extra” charges for decorating the cake… they said anything more would be extra. not sure how that makes sense if you’re ordering a custom cake it shouldn’t start at $60 if that’s the case. so you’re going to give me a cake with no piping just flat starting at $60? with all that being said i was going to pay it because i actually like their cake and i wanted it… but..the manager w

I recently stopped into Martha’s Country Bakery in Astoria and tried a few desserts. I had the Vegan Carrot Cake ($9.75 per slice), the Nutty Apple Cheesecake ($7.95), and the Pecan Cheesecake Bar ($7.95). The cheesecakes were absolutely incredible—rich, creamy, and easily some of the best I’ve ever had. That said, the price point felt a little steep for a single slice/bar, especially compared to other bakeries in the area. The Vegan Carrot Cake, on the other hand, was a bit of a letdown. The cake itself was decent, but the icing lacked that classic cream cheese flavor that really makes carrot cake shine. It felt like it was missing the signature element that makes the dessert so memorable. Overall, it’s a nice spot if you’re looking for some excellent cheesecake and don’t mind paying p

Stopped by Martha’s Country Bakery and got a slice of Triple Chocolate cake. The flavor was rich, with a nice balance of sweetness and cocoa bitterness. The cake was fresh and had a soft texture. I was pleased with it.