Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery

I have been a loyal customer for as long as I can remember. My family and I dine at your restaurant at least once a week and frequently place takeout orders as well. Because of this, I feel it’s important to share an ongoing concern. The dining room has been consistently extremely cold due to NO HEAT. Recently, I came in to eat with a friend and could not tolerate sitting in the back area because of the conditions. It was uncomfortable enough that it affected our dining experience. I find it concerning that a business continues to operate its dining room under these conditions, especially during colder weather. Beyond the impact on customers, I also genuinely feel for the employees who are expected to work in such an environment. I hope this issue can be addressed promptly, as I enjoy y

I come here a ton. Lived in the city for years near some iconic pizza restaurants that I would frequent, and this pizza is right up there with them in my book. Fresh, great tasting pizza/food/ingredients, always have Manhattan Specials (hard to find up here), and most importantly the owners and staff are great people that deliver a family atmosphere and service with a smile! Thank you!!

We had a cheese burger with fries and Parmesan chicken wings. It was pretty good 👍. The waiter was very attentive and nice. She came around a few times to make sure everything was good.

Portions are HUGE! I ordered the chicken parmesan, which came with salad, garlic knots, a bowl of pasta and two big slabs of chicken, all for under $20. The service was fast and friendly. Michelle is a great waitress. I will definitely be back.

Just passing through the area I stopped in for a bite and to my delight... With a last name like mine I know an exceptional slice of pizza when I have one. The crust is flavorful and is the perfect balance of crispy yet soft. The sauce to cheese ratio is to a perfect balance. Truly a distinguished and exceptional slice of pizza. The service experience is flawless. A warm welcoming family & friendly environment that exuberates a passion and desire to ensure everyone they serve is satfied. This is, without a doubt a 5/5 pizzeria. The pizza King of New Windsor.