Mama Mia Pie and Pasta

To the Management of Mama Mia Pie and Pasta, Today we visited Mama Mia Pie and Pasta as a family with our children. When we entered, there was a sign stating “please seat yourself,” so we chose an available table. From the moment the blonde server assigned to our table approached us, the experience became uncomfortable. There was no greeting, no smile, and no effort to make us feel welcome. Simple and reasonable questions about the menu were met with a cold and impatient tone. When ordering for our children, even clarifying a salad dressing option was handled with visible irritation rather than professionalism or helpful guidance. We also politely explained that we do not eat meat and asked if our Margherita pizza could be cut with a clean knife or with extra care to avoid cross-contami

This was hands down one of the worst dining experiences I’ve ever had. We chose Mama Mia Pies and Pasta for my birthday dinner with my wife and friends after a long day of hiking, starving and looking forward to pizza. Unfortunately, this place completely ruined the night. When we arrived, the restaurant felt like a ghost town. We actually had to search for an employee just to get seated, which should have been the first red flag. Although the window view was nice, it was quickly overshadowed by the disgusting condition of the restaurant—spider webs everywhere, dead flies, and spiders crawling around near the windows. We ordered three large pizzas, a chicken Alfredo dinner, and another pasta dish. The server said the order would be placed and coming right out. Nearly an hour later, the pas

Dined here on pizza with my husband on a Tuesday evening. The pizza was fine, I especially loved the toppings on the Gardener’s pizza. A passing hand tossed medium crust, a little floppy. Our server was a little abrupt but accommodating with my dietary need. She seemed in a rush to leave the table every time she came by, which was odd because there were only two other tables occupied and they were being served by other people. 4 stars were for the prices because they seemed a bit high. $60 for just a couple of pizzas and a slice of cake. Also, it took 45 mins or so for the pizzas to come out. It was nice and convenient to our cabin though.

We were so pleased with our Salmon dinner. We looked out on the snow through the back windows and the food was so colorful. We had minestrone soup and mixed vegetables, angel hair pasta with marinara sauce, and warmed rolls. Everything was seasoned perfectly. We had just shoveled 20” of snow and ice off a big deck and braved the roads to get to this restaurant. It was all so worth it. We ordered ahead and ate there- with Moscato.

Pasta and pizza is really good. We have eaten here several times. We recently had an issue with a To-go order (just a mix up on the wrong pizza but we don’t live locally) I called to let them know and to just get the difference but the owner went above and beyond to make it up to us. Highly recommend the pizzas and seafood pasta is a dream!