LUNCH Lobster Roll Amagansett

Absolutely incredible lobster roll — one of the best I’ve ever had! Packed with fresh, tender lobster meat and just the right amount of seasoning, it was buttery, perfectly toasted, and full of flavor without being too heavy. You could tell the ingredients were top quality, and every bite was better than the last. The portion size was generous too, which made it even more worth it. On top of the amazing food, the vibes were spot on. Relaxed, friendly atmosphere with great music, clean space, and a super welcoming staff. Whether you’re hanging out with friends or just grabbing a solo bite, it’s the kind of place that instantly puts you in a good mood. It had that perfect coastal charm without feeling touristy. If you’re in the area and craving a lobster roll done right, don’t miss this spot

Tried the lobster roll here, but honestly, it wasn’t worth the $40 price tag. The taste was decent — fresh lobster meat with a little mayo and celery in a toasted split-top bun — but the portion was small, closer to 4–5 ounces. It only came with a tiny side of coleslaw and a lemon wedge, no chips or fries included. For the cost, I was expecting either a much larger portion or something that felt premium (like butter-poached lobster or an overflowing roll). Instead, it felt like I was paying a “tourist markup.” The quality was fine, but the value just isn’t there. In Montauk, I know prices run high, but $40 for this size roll is really pushing it.

The season’s almost over, but Lunch still reigns supreme! From local oysters (we had Peconic Gold, to seafood chili, fish and chips, lobster rolls and much more, you can’t go wrong! Great service, relaxed atmosphere. Enjoy!!!

Lunch in Amagansett, affectionately known as "The Lobster Roll," is a quintessential East End-Hamptons-Montauk experience that perfectly captures the spirit of a casual, beachy eatery. The iconic roadside sign is a beacon for locals and tourists alike, promising a no-frills meal that focuses on fresh, delicious seafood. The atmosphere is laid-back, with picnic tables under charming red and white awnings, making it the ideal spot for a post-beach lunch.

Best Dinner I’ve had in years. The Seafood Bisque was out of this world. It was so good we ordered a large to go back home for tomorrow. I would recommend this restaurant to anybody In the Montauk area who loves great seafood.