Lost Key Tap Restaurant

We had a great time this evening!! Our server Josh was fantastic as always. Our favorites were the Beet Salad, NY Strip, Salmon, and Gnocchi. The only thing out of what we tried that we might not recommend to a friend is the bolognese. It had a great amount of toppings but was much different from what we imagined. Would love to come back to try more items as it is definitely worth the trip down from Green Bay. They also have a BEAUTIFUL, massive bar that I believe you could eat at if unable to get a reservation :)

We have eaten at The Lost Key many times. The food is always good and they use fresh ingredients. The risotto and salmon are both fabulous. The bartender made a great old fashioned. The trout special with the creamed corn and smashed baby reds was a great combination. We were able to eat at the bar which we like to do. The bartender was friendly and attentive. A little dark for eating, but the inside is very beautiful and clean.

Our first time here for my 5 friends and I. Amazing place as soon as you walk in the door-you get top notch service from the host, and waitresses! The ambiance atmosphere is outstanding! The waitress and host were fantastic, and the food is incredible! Some of us had the burger with truffle fries, walleye and risotto-it was beautifully displayed and the taste was incredible. So much better than the top restaurants in the Green Bay/Appleton area. This is definitely a hidden gem! The bar area is nice and big.. We all loved it, and we will definitely be back often!

Our first visit tonight and it won’t be our last! Amazing service from the moment you walk in the door, excellent food, great drinks, great atmosphere, and very very clean! We spent a little more because we also had some dessert😉

We went here for our anniversary and it was amazing! Josh was our server and Tyler was our bartender! Both extremely great people, super friendly and amazing. Mike did amazing on all the food. Definitely will be coming back to see everyone! The owner Danny was very personable and made us feel very welcomed!!