Keyes Creamery

Keyes is a wonderful spot for homemade ice cream. The shop has a cozy and inviting atmosphere, perfect for enjoying a treat with friends or family. The ice cream tastes fresh, creamy, and full of flavor definitely a step above regular store bought options. The location is convenient, and what makes the experience even better is the service. The staff is welcoming and attentive, and Ebis in particular stands out for being kind, helpful, and genuinely caring about customers. If you’re looking for delicious homemade ice cream served with great hospitality, Keyes is the place to go!

Keys Ice Cream is an absolute gem! The ice cream is rich, creamy, and bursting with flavor—you can tell it’s made with high-quality ingredients and real care. Every scoop tastes fresh and indulgent, whether you go for a classic favorite or one of their creative flavors. The atmosphere is fun and welcoming, and the staff is friendly and patient, even when you’re taking forever to choose because everything looks amazing. It’s the perfect stop for families, date nights, or a simple treat-yourself moment. If you’re an ice cream lover, Keys Ice Cream is a must-visit. Once you try it, you’ll keep coming back 🍦💕

If you are like me, you love an ice cream place where the cows are grazing literally at the edge of the parking lot. The ice cream at Keyes Creamery was very rich. Mostly the standard flavors you find everywhere. But done with care and served by a very friendly staff. note that they charge by weight not by the scoop. So go ahead and pile a little bit extra on. There is no indoor seating, but there’s a generous porch with lots of tables and a pavilion equipped with picnic tables. There is plenty of parking. My only complaint is that there is no indoor bathroom. They do provide a porta potty. sorry, no photos of the ice cream cones. It was melting too fast.

So disappointed when I actually read the ingredients on my $12 quart of ice cream. I grew up in dairy country and if you can’t pronounce half the names of the ingredients, it’s not really homemade creamery ice cream. Caramel color? Propylene glycol? Dextrose? Just to name a few unnecessary ingredients. This stuffs no better than dryers. Where I come from “home made family owned ice cream” contained : milk, cream, cane sugar, egg yolks, non fat milk, and vanilla extract. And I could actually get my spoon into it unlike this paste.

Simply the best ice cream I’ve ever had. Two scoops chocolate and a scoop of graham cracker in the middle, best combo I’ve ever personally imagined. Incredible 🔥