Kersey Pizza

Wow what has happened to Kersey Pizza? For over 15 years we would drive 20 miles out of our way just to get this awesome Pizza. But just got it yesterday and not as good and less toppings than before. We found out it is under new ownership and they changed the menu too. No desert pizza or cinnamon and sugar pizza. These dessert items are a easy money maker too. I have been recommending Kersey Pizza to everyone and have been telling them it is worth the drive for years. NOT ANYMORE. First pic is yesterday September 7th 2025 and second is January this year. Only difference in toppings was old one had peppers and onions. New one less toppings than before and taste was off.

I wanted a Hawaiian pizza. There’s almost no pineapple. Paid for extra sauce They didn’t put it on. I have always loved Kersey pizza, but this Is ridiculous. I will not be ordering again.

Whoever made the pizzas tonight, money in the bank! Been here a bunch but man tonight they were amazing thank you so much!

Hard to recommend. Service was slow, and portions small (and inexpensive). The lasagna was tasty, but took 25 minutes to get out to me, though I was the only one in the place. You don’t have many choices in this small town, and I’m glad they were here to feed me, but tomorrow night I might just take the ten minutes extra to tool into Greeley.

I was recommended to try this place by my husband, who is a truck driver. During a trip I joined him on, we decided to give it a try, and I'm glad we did. The food was fantastic! We ordered a pepperoni pizza, a white slice pizza, and a chicken bacon and cream cheese dish, and everything was delicious. We'll definitely be stopping by again when we're in the area. I highly recommend giving it a try!