Kay Jack Pizza - Madison

“Kay Jack has the best pizza in Lake County”. This is something I regularly say when asked about this place, however, the statement isn’t fair. Lake County doesn’t set the bar very high for food in general, let alone pizza. Mostly what you’ll find here is corporate chains. Kay Jack deserves better than to be compared to other pizza joints in Lake County. I would put Kay Jacks against ANY other pizza joints in the state. It is… truly exceptional pizza. It’s not just “good” by the standard of a “Madisonite” who’s never left Lake County. It’s objectively good and could comfortably stand with pizzas from Little Italy downtown. The dough is homemade and hand rolled. If you can’t “just tell” by the flavor and texture, walk inside and at any given time there’ll be someone rolling dough. The sauc

I had a friend mention Kay Jack Pizza at work and when I saw the pictures I had to try it. It DID NOT disappoint! We went in and ordered and our pizza was ready in 15 minutes. The service was super friendly and the pizza itself was definitely top 3 I've ever had anywhere. Flavor was amazing. We got the cupping peperoni, Italian sausage, banana peppers, and onions with the garlic butter crust finish. Highly recommend this place and I will definitely be back! The only downside was I wish they had tables to dine in....but at the end of the day I'm not to proud to crush a pizza in my car and it won't prevent me from coming back!

Kay Jack is a little out of the way for us so it's not our usual but we were so happy with our meatball pizza and salads we carried out Monday, we may have to make more of an effort to support them. The pizza was amazing, done perfectly and the salad was fresh, crisp romaine - no iceberg - and zero wilted or brown pieces which I usually have to pick through about 90 % of the time. Hope to come back soon!

Loved our food forgot to take a picture until we had already dug in. It was all amazing. Bbq pulled pork, pepperoni and the stuffed cheese bread.

TLDR: It's great, go buy it, it's a little more expensive then most places but get over it..... The quality justifies the price point or to support a local business that doing something awesome. Or just buy two medium cheese pizzas for 12 bucks a piece, it doesn't break the bank. Wall of Text review: Pizza snob review, and hopefully Lay Jack's gets on the One Bite app soon since it's specifically for pizza. To start, they had terrific pizza and especially for our area in Madison/Northeast Ohio it's all fast food pizza or locally owned, high efficiency, medium or low quality pizza available at other places. The cheese melted perfectly and even though we got the pepperoni it was not too greasy. We additionally tried their specially Buffalo pizza and it was very good. The additional garlic