Jumby Bay Island Grill

Visited 3/4/2026 Waitress was friendly, attentive and accommodating. Salmon was good and hot, key lime pie was tasty. Calamari and coleslaw were okay but lobster tails and carrots were cold.

My absolute favorite meal is the poke bowl. It tastes better than when I lived in Hawaii! The chef does a great job with all the dishes and our server Michelle was great.

We recently went to Jumby Bay. It had been awhile since we had last been there. The restaurant was uncomfortably cold, so much so, that we had to move to a different table that was away from the a/c vents. When we got our bill we noticed a $3.50 credit card charge if a customer decides to use a credit card to pay. I’ve never seen that at a restaurant and I think it’s pretty tacky. Personally I think they should just raise their prices and not put that on the bill. That alone makes me not want to go back. The food was okay. Chicken wings were on special…$1 a wing but they were over cooked. The rest of the food was just average. The service was good. Sunny D was our waitress. She was very friendly and efficient. For the most part, our experience was very underwhelming.

Was genuinely in shock by the lack of professionalism by the bartenders who were not only impolite but don’t understand how to communicate respectfully to customers. A polite tone when they are serving you would make a big difference compared to what I had to endure. The staff apart from the bartenders were extremely nice and respectful, which I do appreciate! Friendly grill staff, feisty bartenders- choose your experience wisely! Edit: Thank you for reaching out, I’d be happy to share more details on what happened. Can you please provide an email I can send it to? Thank you!

A fun experience great music, great food options, the seafood salad was really delicious the portions were huge couldn't finish it. The jambalaya was also awesome with a fierce kick. Our waitress was kind, sweet, and very attentive definitely a fun spot to revisit your 90s from a 90210 meets Baywatch vibe 😆