Johnny's Pizza Bryn Mawr

Johnny’s Pizza in Bryn Mawr was the perfect stop after a great Saturday night. I caught Marty Supreme at the Bryn Mawr Film Institute and then walked over for pizza. Easy, convenient, and a great way to end the evening. The pizza was excellent, fresh, and exactly what you want after a movie. Service was smooth and the location makes it an ideal neighborhood spot. I’m also excited to check out Johnny’s Wayne location next, especially since it’s walking distance to our new Real of Pennsylvania real estate office. That review will be coming soon. Highly recommend the Bryn Mawr location.

Johnny’s cheesesteaks are absolutely phenomenal; it’s personally my favorite cheesesteak I’ve had. The roll is excellent; very crisp and flavorful. The meat and cheese are mixed well, and the ratio of meat-cheese-roll is just right! I’ve had cheesesteaks from both the Bryn Mawr and Wayne location and they have always been consistent and every time I have one I remember why I keep coming back! The Wayne location has a beautiful dining area and the Bryn Mawr location’s dining room is a lot of fun and allows patrons to write on the wall; it’s a really fun touch! Highly recommend supporting this business, the service has always been solid and the quality of the food is top notch!

Excellent cheese steaks and pizza. We got the normal round pizza and Cheese steaks with XTRA - Mozzarella and long hot peppers. Very very good. The sitting area has walls where you can tag yourself and or your on line handle name. Super cool. Meaty cheese steak. Not too fatty. Very very good. I’m not a fan of seeded rolls - but darn this was a great roll. Pizza has a nice dusting of grated parmesan cheese that added to the flavor. Remember to go hungry. !

I’ve ordered pizza here multiple times and it’s always burnt and disgusting. Finally I decided to reach out to management to request a refund but they don’t respond. Absolutely terrible customer service here but they don’t care because they get enough business from locals and circulating college students to bother. No good parking for this location either. Not really worth it. There’s plenty of more accessible pizza places with much better tasting options and better customer service. You cannot count on this place to make things right when they sell you a crap products. They also don’t do online or phone orders usually so you need to go in and order to wait for your food to be cooked. Poorly run operation.

It is rumored that a Jimmy's cheesesteak, consumed in its entirety, can cure indecisiveness, grant you the ability to parallel park perfectly on the first try, and make you temporarily immune to passive-aggressive comments from your relatives. These claims are, of course, completely unsubstantiated but passionately believed. I can also asert that their cheesesteak is a must if you haven't been there before.