Joey's Pizza of Hamilton

Joey’s Pizza is seriously one of the more delightful finds in the neighborhood. From the moment you step inside, it feels inviting — clean floors, tidy tables, and a bright counter area that makes you confident they take pride in their space. The restrooms and common areas are kept in great shape too, which always boosts my appetite rather than dampening it. Now, let’s talk about their calzone — wow. It’s absolutely amazing. It arrives piping hot, with a golden-brown crust that’s crisp on the edges yet soft inside. The filling is generous and perfectly balanced: gooey cheese, savory meats (if you choose), fresh herbs, and a sauce that gives just the right tang. It isn’t overstuffed to the point of collapse, but it never leaves you wanting more. The staff here deserve applause. They’re co

This is our go to delivery pizza place. The pizza is great but it's also a smooth process for delivering online or in person/on the phone. The deliverymen are always respectful and nice, and always earlier than they say. I'm so glad I tried this place out. The pizza is delicious and a classic Jersey pie with great crusts. The wings are also great for a party. My go to pizza place, I wish they had a rewards program

Tried this for lunch on a recommendation, it was good, average pizza. Wasnt terrible, but also wasn't 'OMG this is fantastic' pizza either. I have worse and I've had much better.

Was the pizza good? Yes, was it made the way I asked? No. But I would try it again and make sure the hostess actually reads my order back to me.

Such a great place to have a party. Margarita pizza is to die for! So kind and accommodating. Also a clean and spacious place for a larger group