Jimmy's Ice Cream Of East Stroudsburg

Our young server was very cool and collected at the time of serving our party despite the line being long and she handled it very well. Ice cream place got a great selection of ice cream, including vegan. The portions were very good and also very tasty.

*5/5 Stars* I just visited Jimmy's Ice Cream in East Stroudsburg, and I was blown away by the amazing selection of fresh, creamy ice cream and water ice! The water ice is particularly notable for its smooth texture - no chunky bits here! The staff took great care in making each treat, and you can really taste the difference. As a local favorite, Jimmy's Ice Cream is the go-to spot for both ice cream and water ice. Be prepared for a crowd, especially on weekend evenings when it becomes the hot spot in town. But trust me, it's worth the wait! If you're looking for a delicious, high-quality treat that's made with love and care, Jimmy's is the place to be.

Hello, After going to this place three times in the last few weeks we noticed somehow we pay just as much as everyone else but some where in the middle we get less ice cream. Always the same order medium soft serve peanuts and brownies, with two small milk shakes or a large one. Before these 3 times there were other girls always smiling, very polite and made really nice orders, what you expect really when you pay so much for soft serve. But the last 3 visits have just been unaceptable, I am not saying the ice cream should be towering of my cup but do not try to sell me a small for medium either, not cool. Sadly we will not be returning to this place anymore. I am not one to write about everything but sometimes 3 times is once to many.

Lots of ice cream flavors and delicious toppings. Big ice cream parlor with arcade games. Enjoyable for the whole family. Clean, friendly atmosphere.

Went in with the wife and kiddo to eat banana splits on 1/15/26. Girl at the front desk was very professional and welcoming. Banana splits were good and at a good price. Would come again