Jersey Bagel Cafe & Pizza

I’ve stopped here a few times for their fresh, soft bagels, which are always fantastic, so this time I decided to give their pizza a try. The flavor was really good — rich sauce, plenty of cheese, and a nice crust. I ordered what they called a Chicago deep dish, and while it wasn’t the classic thick style I expected, it still tasted amazing once I adjusted my expectations. Their fries are also worth mentioning — thick, golden, and full of flavor. The only thing I’d tweak next time is asking for fresh mushrooms instead of the canned ones, though it didn’t take away from how tasty everything was overall. This place continues to impress, and I’ll definitely keep coming back. Also, I still think they should lean into their name and start offering pizza bagels — that would be perfection!

The bagels taste like stale rolls. They didn’t taste like bagels at all. The everything bagel was way too salty. They were super hard to cut. Wouldn’t recommend wasting your time or calories on it. Service was fine just wish the bagels didn’t taste like a stale roll.

I just stumped on this place is tucked away in a little corner I was pleasantly surprised I got one of the best pizza I had it a long time then I went back for chicken wings it was a nice surprise to find whole chicken wings fried to perfection season extremely well it might be a good idea to stop in and see for yourself I was impressed

You’re only getting the 1 start because the fries were good. The burger nooooo. Just take it off the menu you obviously don’t like making them. Look at the whole lettuce you put in it. Did you even try ? Hope the rest of the food does not go out like this.

First time visiting. Excellent calzone and Baklava. Very cozy place. Friendly employees. The menu has so many delicious options. Can't wait to go back and try something else.