Jeremiah's Tavern

I've been to other Jeremiahs, but this was our first time here. We were seated promptly and Meg Q. Was our server. We ordered the Kenny's Salad with steak and then soup, salad and garlic bread. We both ordered balsamic dressing and it was almost like a thick, gravy consistency. You actually had to put the plastic lid back on the container and shake it in order to pour it on the salads. A different server had brought our food, but no one ever returned to check on us, offer refills, etc. Meg dropped the check and said she can take it when we were ready. My friend had to ask for drink refills. Overall, I would return, based on the menu-there appeared to be a lot of great choices.

I decided to stop at this location while I was in the city for the first time, and ordered the Pow Pow Shrimp. Traditional Wings (5), and Jerry Cheesesteak with macaroni. The shrimp was fried shrimp with some type of sweet sauce drizzled over it. For what it was 5/10. The wings were pretty good and a nice size. If I lived in the area this would be my go to place for wings and drinks. 8/10 Now for the Cheesesteak and my side of macaroni. 4/10. The Cheesesteak itself wasn't nasty it tasted like nothing. Need to be seasoned. For the macaroni I should of checked the bag before leaving because it wasn't in my to go bag.

They were somewhat busy when my husband and I came, yet we waited within a minute. The staff were very friendly and polite. I ordered a bowl of their clam chowder and their pretzels. My husband ordered a build a burger. The chowder was was Amazing! The clam pieces were almost as big as the pieces of potato and Plenty of them! The pretzels were 3 large long soft (breadstick like logs) My husband’s hamburger was cooked to exactly what he asked for. (He rarely gets what he asks for when it comes to being cooked) His words “wow! Cooked to perfection!” Would we recommend this place? Absolutely

We've eaten at Jeremiah's more than at any other restaurant, and it's been great every single time. We decided to place an early online order of wings for the Bills game yesterday, hold them (which we've done many times), and order lunch to eat at home upon return from pickup. We decided to try burgers for the first time, and both were the worst we've ever had. The Bleu Cheese and Chive Burger was ordered medium-rare but came extra well done, burned on the edges, and inedible, so it went straight into the garbage after the first bite. The Morgan Meltdown was edible, but dry and underwhelming, and certainly not worth the price. The order was over 20 minutes late from the indicated pickup time, so I assume the burnt burger was on for an extra 20 minutes. I added a 10% tip, which I won't

Feels like a place that wanted to be a nice bar when it grew up, but never got there. The service is good, but the (expensive) food is just ok. We got take out, which is bad anywhere so I don't hold that against them. But I asked for some plasticware for our salad and they said they didn't have any. I used my own, but what would I do if I didn't have any? You have to have that stuff in stock or don't sell things that require a spoon or a fork. I'll keep my fingers crossed they will improve the quality someday.