Jay's Pizza Shop

I visited Jay’s Pizza Shop and had a good experience. The pepperoni roll was impressively sized and very flavorful, and the crinkle fries were seasoned and prepared perfectly. Service was nice, though the wait for the food was 40 minutes. While the main items were excellent, the cookie was unfortunately a disappointment. It is worth noting there is only one table available for dining in.

We ordered 4 pizzas and chicken wings from here, and waited 8 minutes after the time they said. Their facility was a little dirty and the cooler they keep the wings in was in the waiting area. We drove 1 minute home and half the pizzas were cold. The pizza toppings also just slid right off the pizzas too. The pizza is just ok. I could forgive it all if the pizza was good but it was not.

I ate Jaya pizza for years. This was nothing like it was. I was very disappointed. Crust was over baked, sauce and cheese have changed. I think Jay should try the pizza and make his own decision. I know they bought receipts for pizza and was not to change anything. Also place is very cluttered and not too clean,

One of my top 3 best pizza places in Pittsburgh. The OG pepperoni pizza is Devine. Been eating this pizza for 30+ years and it's always been this good. Would highly recommend. Just got 6 slices and the wife got a steak hoagie.

Ordered delivery, all the food arrived cold, inedible like cardboard. Chuck E. Cheese has better food. Then they basically steal your money & won’t issue a refund for the garbage they delivered.