Jack's Stir Brew Coffee

I needed a cold brew with a kick to give me life after a classics too much fun in the Hamptons night and Jack’s delivered. It was strong, fresh, cold, and delicious. Oh and talk about plenty because this thing was big. I unfortunately did not have an appetite because #hungover but this cold brew brought me back to life. I’ll be back to try some of their vegan bakery items.

The coffee was just fine. The service, too—polite, efficient, nothing to complain about. But the place carries itself with a quiet smugness, like it knows it’s not great but assumes you won’t dare say so. The clientele seem less interested in coffee than in being seen drinking it—an air of casual elitism that clings to the room like the scent of burnt toast. And then there were the six miniature Black and White cookies— $24 for a clamshell that felt more like a status symbol than a snack. If Steinbeck himself baked them they still wouldn’t be worth the price. If you’re after decent coffee and a place to eavesdrop on someone else’s second home renovation plans, this might suit you. But if you're seeking warmth, value, or authenticity, keep walking.

The coffe is bad. And the food had mold. The matcha chia pudding with blueberries were rotten. So I gave it back to them and while I was walking out I notice a young girl also opening the matcha Chia looking disgusted and throwing it away… so it wasn’t only mine.

I never leave reviews, but would leave a zero * if I could. I go to Jack’s probably once a week and the service today was the worst I’ve had ever. The woman making coffee had the lights deliberately turned low, so they looked closed, although it was three hours prior to closing. She looked annoyed she had to make a cup of coffee (black) and was incredibly rude and wouldn’t interact with us. No hello, walked away from us without a word & didn’t turn the screen to pay. Just incredibly rude and awful service. Don’t come to work if you don’t want to be there.

Multiple times now, I have been given the wrong order. The first time it was extremely busy so I shrugged it off because I like the coffee. The second time I was the only one in the place and when I tell them that’s not what I ordered I get an attitude. They tell me what I ordered as if I don’t know what I want when spending $7 on a coffee. Not going back.