Italian Connection Pizza

We used Italian Connection to cater our church's Advent Dinner back in November. Absolutely incredible experience from start to finish. Gary was very responsive, his driver Nick was so kind and helpful. The food was delicious and everyone raved about the meatballs. The generous portions provided by Gary and his team gave us the opportunity to donate what was leftover to the homeless. I look forward to working with them again next year and I highly recommend this business for any catering event.

Great people and great prices. (This review is solely based on a cheese slice) Sadly, the pizza quality has gone downhill over the years. Back in 2010, Italian Connection was my go-to. The slice I got recently was full-on flop jalop, with cheese oozing oil everywhere. Tasted more like something from the Midwest or a late-night drunk slice. Still, $3.75 for a massive slice in 2025 is a steal. I just wish they’d tighten up the quality, even if it means shrinking the slice and charging 4.25 or 4.50 a slice. Win-win for everyone.

Living in the NY/NJ area, we're blessed with an Italian American community that built up businesses providing us with amazing Italian dishes. The Italian Connection is one such place. I haven't had a chance to try the pizza yet, but tried nearly all of their chicken dishes. All of them are top notch. My favorites are the chicken parm and chicken scarpariello. Portions are generous, the sauce is great! Staff is friendly (only ordered take out). There is a covered outdoor seating area which is nice option if you choose to dine in. If I lived closer, I would probably order from here several times per week. If you haven't been here yet, I highly recommend that you try it out. You may find your new italian go-to place.

Whoever is in the kitchen knows what they're doing!! Great value, great flavor. First time ordering from here, and was very pleasantly surprised by all of the dishes (so rare these days). Chicken tenders were clearly made in house, penne vodka full of flavor, chicken francese sandwich tasty, and canolis are top tier. Will definitely order again.

I recently had the unfortunate experience of trying what might be the worst pizza I’ve ever had. From the first bite, it was clear that this was a disaster. The crust was limp and soggy, completely lacking any crispness or structure. Instead of a satisfying chew, it felt like eating wet cardboard. Overall, this pizza was a complete letdown. It had no flavor, no texture, and way too much grease. I wouldn’t recommend it to anyone, unless you enjoy disappointment. I do have to say that the staff was extremely nice and provided my order 15 mins ahead of schedule.