Isabellas Italian — Bentonville

We had such a beautiful and unforgettable experience at this restaurant. My boyfriend proposed to me here, and the entire staff made our special moment even more magical. Everyone was incredibly kind and warm, constantly congratulating us and making us feel truly celebrated. The food was delicious and beautifully prepared. We had already ordered dessert ourselves, but the team surprised us with an additional dessert decorated with a special presentation and a congratulatory message. It was such a thoughtful and touching gesture. Both the servers and the management were amazing — the manager personally came to our table to congratulate us and brought the dessert herself. Their kindness and attention to detail truly made our night perfect. Thank you for making one of the most important mo

Such a wonderful experience and food that stands out in the strong local restaurant scene we have in Bentonville. I put Isabella Italian in the same caliber of food as Preachers Son, Petite Bistro, Mezzaluna Pasteria, easily one of the best meals I've had locally in recent memory. The location lacks some ambiance although beautifully decorated and furnished. What they've accomplished in the space is impressive it's just not an old historic building so you won't have the same vibe as the aforementioned eatery's. Well worth the experience if you've got the urge for something new in Bentonville and a place I'll definitely visit again and again.

Probably one of the best fine dine Italian restaurant in Bentonville AR. I actually visited this restaurant during 'Bentonville restaurant week 2025' when they were running special 2-course menu + house wine. I really liked the food during my dine-in experience. The ambience , the service - all were great. I would definitely return to try their regular menu next time and would also recommend for good Italian food in NWA.

Beautiful dining space, along with a bar, and private party spaces. The food is hearty and delicious! Check their special events calendar for fun evening out ideas!

My wife and I went to Isabella’s for Valentine’s Day this evening. Neither myself nor my wife had eaten here before so we had no prior knowledge of what to expect. We made reservations and were the second couple to arrive upon Isabella opening. The attire of the servers with the white tops did give it a clinical feel per a previous review. Atmosphere felt rather cold due to all the blue coloring within the facility. My wife and I typically will look at the menu before we arrive at a restaurant, after we ordered it had been maybe 20 minutes before our server told us that there was an issue in the kitchen and that the cooks weren’t able to see that orders had been placed due to technical error even though it was Valentine’s Day and you’d expect customers to be there upon opening which delaye