Holy Pepperoni | Apizza Joint

Maybe today was a fluke? My daughter was told to try it and was excited to try it. But it was disappointing. It is significantly more expensive than other pizza places in the area. Takes over 45 mins to get. I was excited to try the garlic cheese sticks. But only two sticks appeared to have cheese on it and I couldn't really make out any garlic taste. Pizza was rather bland. Plus, for a place to be called holy pepperoni but have so little pepperoni on the pizza is odd as well. I like the crust. My husband didn't like any of it. My daughter said that it was ok. I am hoping that we just caught this place on a bad day. But we have so many other pizza places that I am uncertain if we will try this again. It is out of the way, more expensive, takes longer, and not particularly special. This was

Ok, let's be fair. This is absolutely not New Haven style pizza. It's floppy, not crispy, and there's no char. But, it's a pretty solid New York style pie. If you're expecting a Sally's, Modern, or Frank Pepe pie, you're going to be disappointed. However, if you're after that slice you had right off Times Square, you're golden. The eat in experience is lacking. No real plates or silverware, no service, order at the counter. Also, there's no music so prepare to whisper.

Holy Pepperoni is absolutely amazing! The pizza was fresh, flavorful, and easily some of the best I’ve had in a long time. The staff were incredibly friendly and welcoming, which made the whole experience even better. If you’re craving great pizza with great service, this is the place to go! And the Cannolis🤌🏼👨🏼‍🍳💋

Pizza is ok, lots of flop, oily. The dough is a sourdough and has good flavor. Salads are overpriced. It was spring mix from Wal-Mart with cherry tomatoes. There was no spinach in the salad as advertised. Wings are oven baked, we did not enjoy them. Ingredients seemed fresh on the pizzas. May try it again in a couple months.

The most delicious crust ever, perfect flavors and super nice staff!!! The dining area is so cozy, this is definitely our new go to pizza place!!