Heavenly Pizza- Tiffin

Salad was good, cheese sticks was good. The pizza was gross 😝. It was pretty much raw and very doughy. It was a carryout order and if I lived closer it would have been returned. I only ate 1 slice the other people in the house said the same thing more than half of the pizza is left.

I must give credit where credit is due! This small, locally owned business was truly our saving grace on the night of our homecoming! Our middle schoolers had a dance that ended at 7. We had reservations for 30 for the side patio at another local restaurant but when we arrived we had realized they had accidentally overbooked the patio and there was no longer room to accommodate us. We were panicking trying to find another place to welcome 15+ rowdy boys & their parents. We called Heavenly Pizza & they were AMAZING!!! The staff welcomed us with open arms. I'm sure it was overwhelming and annoying for them to see 30+ people walk into their doors but they never let us see them sweat! They were soooo friendly and got our food out SO quickly despite the massive load we had bestowed upon them.

Paid for my order online and due to a glitch the app asked me to call to place the order. When I arrived to pick up my order, My card declined and I realized that the app had stolen my last $30 for dinner. Thanks to their low quality app and issues due to their side, my girlfriend and I will not be able to afford dinner AT ALL tonight. Love the food but place really screwed me over.

Sub par pizza. The Cheese wasn't even to the edge of the pizza. Then when ordering the cost was 6 dollars more than the coupon because of "premium" toppings. Seriously? For a "Christian" business, that's not very good transparency. 29.95 for a three item jumbo, unless you want bacon or something other than onion on your pizza. Long gone are the days of affordable good food.

PIZZA was GREAT, staff was very nice and welcoming. The new building is fantastic, seeing a local business grow makes me feel great. Always a go too always the best! Thank you AJS for YEARS OF GREAT FOOD!