Handel's Homemade Ice Cream

A Sweet Treat Worth Waiting For I recently visited Handel's Homemade Ice Cream in Fishers, and it was a delightful experience. The ice cream is truly homemade and made fresh daily, offering an impressive selection of over 50 flavors. Highlights: - Delicious Flavors: From classic Chocolate Pecan to unique flavors like Graham Central Station and Cake Batter, there's something for everyone. - Homemade Goodness: The ice cream is crafted in-house using high-quality ingredients and traditional recipes. - Friendly Service: Despite the long lines, the staff is courteous and accommodating. Area for Improvement: - Service Speed: Be prepared for potentially long wait times, as the lines can easily go around the building. While the staff is friendly, the service could use some speed to manage t

My to go place when I'm craving Pistachio flavored ice cream. The one thing I love the most is that it actually has a good amount of pistachios in it.

I tried the sampler 4 dip. I got pistachio, coconut cream pie, smores and spouse big as a house. Let me tell you all the spouse one is amazing!! I loved it and wanted to lick the container!! Next was smores, it was also very good. The pistachio could use a little more flavor and the coconut cream was ok. Ill definitely visit again

My lovely bride and I stopped by for some delicious ice cream. She had PB chocolate chunk and I had the black cherry. She liked hers but thought it could use a touch more PB for her taste. I thought mine was fine. Quite a few people here but the staff was quick and efficient. Yeah a little pricey for ice cream but I figure it’s Fishers so their overhead has to be kinda high. We will be back.

Service 5 stars, and you can try your ice cream before you buy! The hurricane is softer virgin of iceream I really liked , but my favorite flavor by far was COFFEE.