Gus's Pizza Shop

This is the local small town pizza shop, pickup style shop. Pizza is more unique than the rest of the cookie cutter NY shops. It costs a little more but you actually get a pizza from the 1980's, full crust, thick cheese layer, pepperoni has a flavor but isn't overpowering, and cooked to perfection. Quality costs sometimes and the price here is well worth it. Staff is always friendly and never acting fake just to get your business. Definitely the choice taste of the local pizza. Definitely a local business worth supporting. The parking is street side and the shop is a mom and pops to go pizza shop. I've been all over the country and this shop is high in my top five after the first bite. A homegrown Pennsylvania pizza place instead of a NY imitation.

Regarding the pizza order placed on September 27th, I am writing to detail the unsatisfactory experience. The initial issue involved an oven malfunction, which led to an offer of a refund if the pizza was not satisfactory. Upon receiving the pizza, it was undercooked, and subsequent attempts to resolve the issue were unsuccessful. Despite ordering a sheet pizza with 14 cuts, a medium pizza with six cuts was provided as a replacement. The quality of the replacement pizza was also subpar. Furthermore, the staff's handling of the situation was unprofessional, including accusations of dishonesty and a refusal to honor the initial agreement. This experience resulted in receiving an incorrect and poorly prepared order, coupled with disrespectful treatment from the staff. I hope that this feedbac

Was not impressed I thought it was regular slices but no it's square Sicilian slices but the crust was to thin you have to stack 7 or 8 slices just to get a real Sicilian slice

If I could give negative-five stars I would! They charge $3 per bottle of soda as opposed to $2.25; the cans of soda are $1.65 as opposed to $1.25. Food quality has suffered heavilly and customer service has declined greatly. I'm never wasting my money here ever again be cause of price gouging on sodas! 😡🤬👎👎

My dad would surprise us and bring Gus's along when he would visit me growing up! Locally owned & operated! It's pretty much the same exact way it was from the beginning! U can order by the pie or square cuts! We usually get a "Half Sheet" which is 14 square cuts!! They offer a meal deal with pizza, chips and 2 liter combos of your choice. Good selection of toppings. Very casual. Call to order ahead or just stop in for some “cuts”. Great for ordering numerous pizza’s for parties or events. Wheel chair accessible. Walk in. Stand while you wait. Commercial size ovens get your order hot and ready in no time at all! Check em out! They are within walking distance to town! Help Support our local businesses! Ur kids will thank you for it! Seem to have irregular hours now and they haven’t been op