Greek Island Diner

Great food with generous portions and incredibly fair prices. My cheeseburger was delicious, and my husband’s souvlaki was equally fantastic. We were seated immediately and our server was attentive and awesome. We will definitely be back!

Had a great experience at this diner! The staff were super friendly and welcoming, and the food was so delicious — the portions are huge (come hungry, lol). Definitely a place I’d come back to again!

Well I was a regular at the restaurant the food is ok but was greasy (fries and fish) . Now the part that angered me when I walked up to pay at the counter where you first walk in I heard a voice I can help you over here at a second checkout counter so I placed my food take home bag on the counter to get my wallet out. Then I paid the lady and she said that the bag I just put on the counter was a take out order that someone is picking up. Sometimes I think people are on drugs or under the influence of something. I told her that it was my leftover food and she proceeded to put her hands in my bag to check for herself. That is the mistake she made. No apology made. Now I took it as a major insult to me and will have a hard time returning to this place.

Everything we got was on point and delicious. The quality of produce, the care with which it was cooked and served made for a very pleasant experience.

Outstanding traditional gyro with tender meat and plenty of fresh lettuce and tomato. Very large serving. Tzatziki sauce was so good, perfectly cool, garlicky cucumber perfection. If you found my review helpful, please give it a like! Hometown setting, home made food, lightning fast accurate service. Beautiful, fresh selection of cakes and pastries. Coffee refills (and they remembered I ordered decaf!) brought to our table by cheerful waitstaff. Our server Michelle was genuinely happy and made us feel like valued, appreciated customers. Highly recommend as you head down Island to Orient or Greenport.