Goodfellas Pizzeria

I LOVED IT! My spouse and I both have Alpha-Gal and are gluten-free. We ordered a LARGE gluten-free chicken ranch (without the bacon and stressed the importance of our allergy to it). I haven't had a large pizza in years. I also haven't had the parmesan cheese and crushed red pepper packets in ages. First time eating at a Goodfellas. I really enjoyed this experience. The staff was friendly and helpful! The crust is cauliflower and the cauliflower taste is noticeable (just in case this is an issue; it wasn't for me). Overall, we're very satisfied customers.

The pizza here is really good. Some of the best. So is the cheese bread. I got the Pepperoni. Pretty good prices for what you get. Plus we there wasn't to long of a wait. cozy atmosphere. The staff was friendly. The decor was cool to look at while we waited.

A nice little pizza joint. Older Building with character... Lots of OU and Oklahoma memorabilia. Starters... Chef Salad, see the picture. Maybe a cup of Iceberg lettuce with a few diced tomatoes and onions, a handful of croutons. And a minimal amount of ham and less than strip of bacon. Someone made a lot of money on this. Pizza.. The Boss basically a supreme pizza. We got the large. The original crust was good, nothing fancy. The sauce was a little to sweet to me, but good overall. Generous amounts of toppings which all seemed good quality. Cheese bread... Basically a pizza crust with a buncha cheese melted on it. Not bad overall, but a little over cooked on the crust. Canned/bottled soda. Very nice staff. The place was charming overall. Above average pizza.

Surprised in Vinita. Goodfellas has a throwback style pizza and crust, lots of cheese and the sauce was bright. Plenty of toppings, and they were fresh and flavorful. Atmosphere was a mishmash of old school memorabilia and classic cars and art. Bathroom was very clean.

The cheeseburger pizza 🍕 is absolutely delicious. Loaded with tons of cheese and toppings. The boss is just as good and ham sandwich is wonderful.