Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mainstrasse

Triple check your order to make sure the site doesn't kick it to a different location. Because of that the pizza I ordered sat for a while which made it have a rubber consistency. The way they wrapped up the sub should be a crime. When taking the sub out of the bag, my son lost his poor meatball all covered in sauce it fell on his lap and then rolled across the floor!

My husband and I visited this pizza place for dinner and had a great experience. We ordered a vegetarian pizza which had NY-style crispy crust and apt amount of cheese and turned out delicious. The outdoor seating area had a cozy ambience, making it a nice spot to hang out. The staff were friendly, and it was a pleasant surprise when they brought the pizza to our table despite it being self-service usually and even gave a complimentary cheesecake for my birthday - a lovely gesture!

ALL OF THE LADIES AND GENTLEMEN WORKING THE EVENING LATE NIGHT SHIFT OF 1/16 DESERVE A RAISE. I was a cincinnati native that moved to texas and the BEST part of coming home and visiting my favorite pizza shop was the even further impeccable service. Thank you all for providing food and customer service that represents the same sweet memory of my city that I so dearly love. GIVE EM A RAISE!!!

Ordered two slices for dine in and a half pepperoni and cheese to go. Poor execution all around. Slices probably reheated for 30 sec and came out room temp. We sat there for 10 min after take out pizza was done and had to go to counter to ask if it was ready. How did they not tell us our pizza was ready is so odd. When it came out - whopping 5 slices of pepperoni. Potential but execution and service sucked. Ps: Pizza was more like a 14” than 16” as can be seen by pic. Update: I went to the Pleasant Ridge location last week and it was a much different experience. All the pizzas were coming out high-quality, attention to detail and tasted good. I’ll go back to this one in the future.

Order the buffalo chicken bread. This is the best thing I have ever had, and it tops it off by eating at the fountain right outside the restaurant. Praise Reese and Austin for this amazing dish! They were so nice. Would come again.